Sip a cider while you muse over my list of endearing fall this-or-that questions about activities, traditions, food, Thanksgiving, and Halloween.
Read my other conversation starters here; there are 65 of them!
You may also like GTQ’s fall would you rather questions.
Fall Activities This or That Questions
- Apple picking or pumpkin picking?
- Pecan pie or pumpkin pie?
- Sitting by a cozy fireplace or a bonfire?
- Jumping in leaves or apple picking?
- Wandering around a corn maze or enjoying a hayride?
- Fall festivals or craft shows?
- Take a hike through a mountain to enjoy the changing leaves, or go to a pumpkin-picking patch.
- Carving a jack-o-lantern or making a scarecrow?
- Painting a pumpkin for carving a pumpkin?
- Hiking to admire the fall foliage or camping on the chilly fall nights?
- Watching a football game or playing football?
- Thanksgiving or Halloween?
- Oktoberfest parade or Thanksgiving parade?
- Having guests over for a potluck or going to someone else’s house for dinner?
Fall Traditions This or That Questions
- Pumpkin-scented candles or apple-scented candles?
- Fall decor around the house or waiting until Christmas?
- Spend the day cozy under a blanket, reading a book, or going on an adventure in the woods?
- Chai tea latte or pumpkin spice latte?
- Mulled wine or apple cider?
- Foliage road trip or city ghost tour?
- Samhain ritual or fall equinox celebration?
Fall Food This or That Questions
- Roasted butternut squash or roasted sweet potatoes?
- Turkey or ham?
- Roasted chestnuts or roasted pecans?
- Cranberry jelly or cranberry sauce?
- Butternut squash soup or turkey soup?
- Apple cider or hot chocolate?
- Apple tart or pumpkin cheesecake?
- Mashed potatoes or stuffing?
- Roasted sprouts or sweet potato casserole?
- Green bean casserole or collard greens?
- Dinner rolls or cornbread?
- Hearty chili or pumpkin soup?
- Maple-glazed carrots or mashed sweet potatoes?
- Cranberry sauce or gravy on mashed potatoes?
- Cranberry sauce or gravy on turkey?
- Stuffing cooked inside a turkey or separately?
- Waldorf salad or cranberry salad?
Fall Desserts This or That Questions
- Freshly baked pie or freshly baked bread?
- Maple fudge or pecan pralines?
- Apple pie or apple crisp?
- Candy corn or caramel apples?
- Pumpkin muffins or banana bread?
- Apple cider donuts or pumpkin spiced muffins?
- Pumpkin loaf or cinnamon buns?
- Warm apple pie with ice cream or warm brownie with whipped cream?
- Maple syrup or whipped cream on pancakes?
Halloween This or That Questions
- Costume party or trick or treating?
- Handing out candy for Halloween or trick or treating?
- Corn mazes or haunted houses?
- Thanksgiving decorations or Halloween decorations?
- Fall wreaths or spooky decorations?
- Harvest festival or haunted house?
- Scary movie marathon or a romantic comedy marathon?
- Fall-themed graphic long-sleeve shirt or Halloween-themed graphic long-sleeve shirt?
Thanksgiving This or That Questions
- Halloween treats or a Thanksgiving feast?
- Turkey dinner or roast beef dinner?
- Hosting a friend’s Thanksgiving or helping at a community drive?
You may also like GTQ’s Thanksgiving conversation starters to help navigate awkward situations!
Final Thoughts
Did you have fun making choices in our fall this or that game?
We’re eager to hear your choices – let us know in the comments!
Our Fall Games
- Fall Trivia Quiz
- Fall Party Games
- Fall This or That Questions
- Fall Would You Rather Questions
- Halloween Trivia Quiz
- Halloween Movies Trivia Quiz
- Halloween Music Trivia Quiz
- Conversation Starters
- Fun Games
- Trivia Quizzes
